Dry the heater, put paper under it and wait an hour. Water coming from the top is a fitting you can tighten. Water from the drain valve is a cheap fix, often just its washer. Water arriving at the floor with everything above it dry means the tank has rusted through, and that one is a new heater.
A water heater leaking onto the floor tells you almost nothing on its own, because water runs down the outside of the tank and collects at the bottom no matter where it started. A loose fitting or a dripping valve can look exactly like a tank that has failed.
So the first job is finding the exact spot, and that takes an hour of waiting rather than any skill.
Before you start
Gas or electric? Both leak in the same four places, so this page covers both. The shutdown is the only part that differs and it is in the next section.
What to carry: a torch, a dry rag, some paper towel or newspaper, and a small mirror if the back of the tank is against a wall. Nothing else. The job is looking, not fixing, until you know which of the four it is.
Shut it down first
On a gas heater turn the gas control knob to OFF, not to pilot. On an electric heater switch off the double breaker marked water heater.
Then close the cold water valve on the pipe going into the top of the tank. That is the whole shutdown and it takes a minute. The tank stays hot for hours, so you are not rushing.
Dry it and wait
Wipe every wet surface dry: the top fittings, the sides, the valve, the floor. Then lay paper towel under the heater and around the base, and leave it alone for an hour.
When you come back, the wet paper shows you where the water lands, and a dry fitting that is wet again shows you where it comes from. That hour can save the price of a new heater.
The four places a water heater leaks
The two pipes on top
Dry both connections and the short pipes under them, then look again after the hour.
A slow weep up here runs down the outside of the tank and puddles at the bottom, which is exactly what makes people buy a heater they did not need. Often it is a union that has loosened, and a quarter turn with a wrench ends it.
The T and P valve, and its pipe
The lever on the side or the top with a pipe running down towards the floor. If that pipe is wet, the valve opened because the pressure or the temperature got too high, and it did its job.
That is a pressure fault, not a valve fault. Turn the thermostat down to 120. Rheem says that in a closed water system, thermal expansion can push the pressure up to the valve’s setting on every heating cycle, so if it keeps letting go, the expansion tank has failed or the house needs one. Replacing the valve without fixing the pressure just moves the leak.
The drain valve at the bottom
The tap near the floor. Wipe it dry and hold a tissue under the spout for a minute.
Often it drips because the washer inside has been disturbed, for example after the tank was drained, not because anything broke. A brass replacement valve is cheap, and the tank has to be drained to change it.
The seam at the bottom of the tank
If everything above is dry after the hour and water still arrives at the floor, it is coming from between the steel tank and the outer jacket, which means the tank has rusted through from the inside.
Nothing seals that. The tank is a steel drum with a glass lining, and once the lining fails the steel goes. A.O. Smith puts a tank’s life at 8 to 12 years, and Rheem says to inspect the anode rod every year and replace it when more than 6 inches of its core wire shows.
What the blinking light means
Gas heaters with an electronic control blink a status light through the little window, and the pattern is the fault. Worth reading before you decide anything, because a heater that overheats can push water out of the T and P valve. These are the codes for the Honeywell (Resideo) WT8840 control.
| Blink pattern | What the maker calls it | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| 1 flash every 3 seconds | Normal operation | Nothing wrong with the control |
| 2 flashes | Thermopile low voltage | The pilot burns but is not making enough power |
| 4 flashes | Temperature cut-out limit reached | The water got too hot and the control shut the gas off. Heat like that can also open the T and P valve |
| 7 flashes | Electronics failure | Resideo says replace the control module |
The label inside the door gives the pattern for your own make, and the codes are not the same between them.
Questions people ask
Is a leaking water heater dangerous?
A slow drip is not. A swollen tank, or hot water forcing its way out, is. Gas plus water on the floor is also a reason to stop and call somebody.
Can I keep using hot water while it drips?
For a day or two, with a bucket under it and the temperature turned down to 120. Not longer, because the water reaches the floor, the wall and whatever is stored down there.
Water is only there some mornings.
That is usually the T and P valve letting go while the heater reheats overnight, which points at pressure or a thermostat set too high: how to test a water heater thermostat.
It leaks and there is no hot water either.
Two separate things, and the no hot water part is usually the element or the pilot: how to test a water heater element.
How long should a water heater last?
A.O. Smith says a tank water heater typically lasts 8 to 12 years. After that, a leak from the bottom is the normal ending, not a fault. The age is in the serial number: how old is my water heater.
Sources: Rheem use and care manual AP23698 (thermal expansion, anode rod, temperature setting), the Honeywell (Resideo) WT8840/WT8860 gas control installation instructions 34-00013EF (status light codes), and A.O. Smith "How Long Do Tankless Water Heaters Last?" (tank life)
By



