Heat Pump Running Constantly: When It Is Normal
In cold weather a heat pump that runs without stopping is usually doing exactly what it was designed to do, and it is cheaper that way. The test is whether the house holds its temperature. Running nonstop and holding is normal. Running nonstop on a mild day and still falling behind is a fault worth finding.
If you have come from a furnace, a heat pump that runs all day in January feels like something is wrong. Usually nothing is.
A furnace heats in short hot bursts. A heat pump heats gently and for a long time, and as it gets colder outside it has less to give and runs longer to keep up. Nonstop running in a cold snap is the design working, not failing.
Before you start
What to carry: a thermometer, and a note of the outdoor temperature. Twenty minutes across a day.
Is it a heat pump? Heat pumps are all electric. If your heating burns gas or oil, you have a furnace, and nonstop running means something different: how long each kind of system should run.
Watch two things, not one. Whether it is running, and whether the house is holding the temperature you set. Those two together are the whole answer.
It runs nonstop and the outdoor coil is a solid block of ice that never clears. A heat pump iced over like that is barely heating at all: when the ice is not normal.
Why cold weather makes it run nonstop
Find the balance point for your house
The house loses more heat the colder it gets. Double the difference between inside and out, and the heat leaking through the walls roughly doubles.
The heat pump makes less the colder it gets, because it is pulling heat out of colder air.
Somewhere those two meet. That outdoor temperature is the balance point. It is different for every house, and on many ordinary systems it sits somewhere around freezing.
Above it, the heat pump has spare capacity and cycles on and off. Below it, it runs flat out all the time, and the thermostat brings in the backup electric heat to make up the difference.
So nonstop running on a cold day is a sign it is sized sensibly, not badly. A heat pump big enough never to run constantly would short cycle and do a poor job of drying the air for the rest of the year.
Normal, or a fault
Put it against the weather
Cold outside, running nonstop, house holding temperature. Normal. Nothing to do.
Cold outside, running nonstop, house slipping a degree or two in the coldest part of the night. Also usually normal, and it is what the backup heat is for.
Mild outside, forty degrees or above, running nonstop and falling behind. Not normal. A heat pump should have plenty of capacity at that temperature. Something is holding it back.
Air from the vents feels cool. Heat pump air is warm rather than hot, around 85 to 100 degrees, Carrier says. Measure it before judging it by hand: what heat pump air should measure.
In summer, nonstop running on the hottest days is the same story as any air conditioner: why a system runs all day and holds 78.
When it is a fault, the likely causes
The causes, cheapest first
A clogged filter. Starved of air, a heat pump moves less heat and runs longer. First thing to check, every time: how often a filter really needs changing.
A dirty outdoor coil. In winter the outdoor coil is where the heat comes from, and a matted coil gathers less of it.
A deep overnight setback. Dropping the thermostat six degrees at night means a long recovery every morning, often on the expensive backup heat. Small setbacks only on a heat pump.
Low refrigerant. A heat pump that is short of charge runs longer and heats less, and it gets worse every year: why low refrigerant always means a leak.
A defrost problem. A coil that never fully clears spends the whole day half blocked.
The fan setting. If it is the indoor fan that never stops rather than the heat pump, check the thermostat fan is on Auto, not On. Many variable speed systems also run the fan slowly on purpose between cycles.
Questions people ask
Does running constantly mean a huge bill?
Not by itself. A heat pump running steadily at low output is at its most efficient. The bill climbs when the backup electric heat does most of the work, which is why the setback matters so much.
Should I switch to emergency heat when it is very cold?
Only if the heat pump itself has failed. Emergency heat turns the heat pump off and runs only the electric backup, which costs two to three times as much for the same warmth.
What is a normal balance point?
It depends on the house and the system. Around freezing is common for ordinary systems, and cold climate heat pumps can hold on much lower. There is no single right number.
It runs constantly and the house is too warm.
That is the thermostat or the controls rather than the heat pump. Check the thermostat is set to what you think, and that it is not in a draught or in direct sun.
The outdoor fan stops but the unit keeps making noise.
That is almost certainly a defrost cycle, a few minutes of noise and steam, and it is meant to happen: which heat pump noises are normal.
Is a variable speed heat pump meant to run all the time?
More or less, yes. They are built to run long and slow at part speed rather than start and stop, and that is where they save the most.
Sources: Carrier "Heat Pump vs Furnace: Which System is Right for You?" (longer cycles than a furnace) and "Heat Pump Not Heating? Troubleshooting Cold Air Issues" (85 to 100 degree air, fan on Auto), Trane "What Is a Dual Fuel Heat Pump System?", "At What Temperature Do Heat Pumps Stop Working?" (full capacity to around 32°F) and "What Is an HVAC Load Calculation?" (oversizing), Google Nest Help "Heat Pump Balance" (AUX heat), and the DOE Energy Saver Guide 2017 (setbacks on a heat pump)
By 


